I was late to the comic book scene. I never even picked up and read one until I was in college. Once I did, however, like everything else I get into, I went whole-hog. I picked up a good $10 to $30 per week habit which, in the early-1990’s, amounted to three to seven comic books per week. Over the course of two years or so, I had acquired quite an extensive collection.
I have to admit, Cap was not one of my regular reads. I’d pick up an issue here and there, so I knew enough about him that I wasn’t totally confused when he popped up in another series. So, it is with this background that I went to the movie last night.
To be honest, I was a little skeptical at first; most movies, especially superhero movies, seem to disappoint me. I was expecting to see bad acting, poor dialog, unbelievable action and oh-too-obvious predictability. I was pleasantly surprised.
The opening scene shows us a weak and sickly Steve Rogers trying again, unsuccessfully, to volunteer for the military during World War II. I think they did a great job establishing his character’s personality and motivation. Just as impressive was the CG hiding Chris Evans’s physique beneath a skinny and short frame; I didn’t really detect any of the telltale signs of computer gimmickry. Also well-done was the portrayal of his relationship with his best friend Bucky Barnes, important to later scenes in the movie.
I’m not 100% certain that the origin story was true-to-canon, with the super-soldier serum and vitarays, but I enjoyed it. It didn’t stretch the suspension of disbelief within the superhero genre, so I was able to roll with it and remain engaged with the story.
I was especially pleased with the portrayal of the villain, Johann Schmidt, a.k.a. Red Skull. His motivation was simple and clear, which is to be expected in a comic-book antagonist. I also have to compliment the timing of Red Skull’s unveiling – it was perfect, unlike the villain in another film of recent memory.
Finally, the action in the movie was excellent. It was only slightly over-the-top, and just a little cheesy – exactly what the Silver Age Comics genre calls for. Not once did I roll my eyes or say to myself, “Oh, please!” Again, it stayed within the bounds of credibility that it had set for itself.
The conclusion was pretty much exactly what I predicted it would be a quarter of the way into the movie. However, I really can’t call this a disappointment. On the contrary, I was pleased with the ending, and may have been disappointed if it were any different. I say this as a fan of comic book tropes, especially in the Silver Age – the last page has to close the loop.
A bonus for those of us who stay until the credits are finished: you will catch a trailer for the upcoming movie The Avengers. I’m glad that Mike and I both have the habit of waiting to the very end.
Oh, and I am very pleased to report that the movie did feature a scene with steak. Colonel Phillips brought a platter to… oh, no, wait – I won’t spoil it if you haven’t seen it yet.
BeefGriller’s Rating: 5 Steaks(Prime Rib)
Tuesday, 26 July 2011 at 12:54 PM
The best superhero movie of the summer – good acting, good special effects, good storyline, and a heaping dollop of patriotism. Whoever thought Evans could have made such a great Captain America too! Good Review! Check out mine when you can!